Each club's likely penalty takers are ranked from most probable on the left to least probable on the right. Each percentage estimates the chance that the player takes a penalty awarded to his club, conditional on him appearing at some point in the match. It does not model whether he will be on the pitch at the precise minute a penalty is awarded, and the figures in a row do not necessarily add up to 100%. Players without an official FPL penalty order are included only if they have taken a Premier League penalty this season.
| Team | Most Probable ⟶ Least Probable | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Arsenal | Saka, 54% | Gyökeres, 38% | Ødegaard, 2% | ||
| Aston Villa | Buendía, 49% | Watkins, 37% | |||
| Bournemouth | Kluivert, 54% | Tavernier, 36% | Kroupi.Jr, 0% | ||
| Brentford | Thiago, 81% | Schade, 6% | Jensen, 2% | ||
| Brighton | Groß, 51% | O'Riley, 38% | |||
| Chelsea | Palmer, 80% | Enzo, 13% | Estêvão, 2% | Delap, 1% | |
| Coventry City | Wright, 81% | Torp, 9% | Grimes, 2% | Thomas-Asante, 1% | |
| Crystal Palace | Mateta, 63% | Sarr, 25% | Devenny, 5% | ||
| Everton | Ndiaye, 81% | Barry, 5% | Garner, 2% | Beto, 2% | |
| Fulham | Robinson, 82% | Iwobi, 7% | |||
| Hull City | Crooks, 81% | McBurnie, 7% | |||
| Ipswich Town | Hirst, 81% | Clarke, 6% | Philogene, 2% | ||
| Leeds | Calvert-Lewin, 77% | Nmecha, 13% | Piroe, 2% | ||
| Liverpool | Isak, 50% | Szoboszlai, 41% | Gakpo, 2% | Mac Allister, 2% | Wirtz, 2% |
| Man City | Haaland, 81% | Marmoush, 10% | Semenyo, 5% | Doku, 2% | Matheus N., 1% |
| Man Utd | B.Fernandes, 81% | Mbeumo, 5% | Tielemans, 2% | ||
| Newcastle | Woltemade, 81% | Osula, 9% | Wissa, 2% | ||
| Nottm Forest | Wood, 51% | Igor Jesus, 25% | Gibbs-White, 16% | ||
| Spurs | Solanke, 71% | Kudus, 10% | Richarlison, 5% | Xavi, 0% | |
| Sunderland | Diarra, 60% | E.Le Fée, 34% | |||